Skip to content
Whisk Sweetly

Japanese Clear Soup with Tofu and Mushrooms

A clear kombu and shiitake broth seasoned with light soy and sake, with soft tofu, enoki and fresh shiitake, finished with ginger juice. Vegan, light and ready in 30 minutes.

Prep
10 min
Cook
20 min
Rest
30 min
Makes
Serves 4
Jump to the recipe
A bowl of clear Japanese soup with tofu beside a bento box
Photo: Marvin Sacdalan / Pexels

A Japanese clear soup is almost entirely broth, so the broth is the recipe. The tofu and mushrooms are there to be tasted through it, not to carry it. That broth is dashi, and the vegan version here gets its depth from two ingredients that are full of glutamate: kombu, a dried kelp, and dried shiitake mushrooms. Together they taste far more savory than either one alone, which is why this soup can be satisfying with nothing else in it.

Kombu gives up its flavor in warm water, not boiling water. Soak it for thirty minutes, then heat it slowly and take it out just before the water simmers, at about 150°F (65°C) if you have a thermometer, or when small bubbles first cling to the sides of the pot. Boil kombu and it releases a slippery, slightly bitter taste that clouds the broth. The dried shiitake are the opposite. They need the long soak and then a real simmer to give up their flavor, so they stay in after the kombu comes out.

Clear means clear. A clear soup is seasoned with salt first and soy sauce second, because soy adds color as well as salt. Light soy sauce, called usukuchi, is saltier and paler than the regular kind and keeps the broth the color of weak tea. If you only have regular soy sauce, use a little less and make up the salt with salt. Add a splash of sake for roundness. Then taste the broth on its own before anything else goes in. It should taste complete, a little more seasoned than seems right, since the tofu will dilute it.

The tofu and mushrooms are warmed, not cooked. Soft or silken tofu breaks up if the soup boils, so slide the cubes in once the heat is low and let them sit until they are hot through. Enoki and fresh shiitake need only two minutes. Ginger goes in at the very end as juice squeezed from grated ginger, so it tastes bright and sharp instead of cooked. A grating of fresh ginger left in the bowl makes the soup cloudy.

For a more sour, warming bowl, add a teaspoon of Chinese black vinegar to each serving with the ginger. That pulls it toward a Chinese-style soup, and it is very good on a cold night.

It makes a light first course before something richer, such as baked tilapia with fried plantains. For another clear broth with a different trick to it, egg drop soup is built the same way: season the broth first, then add the main ingredient gently at the end.

Two small bowls of clear broth with tofu and chopsticks on a dark table
Photo: HirokazuTouwaku / Pixabay

Clear tofu and mushroom soup at a glance

Total time
1 hr
Yield
Serves 4

Kombu, shiitake, soy and the bowl

Kombu and shiitake dashi

  • 5 cups (1.2 liters) cold water
  • 1 piece kombu, about 4 x 4 inches (10 x 10 cm), about 10 g
  • 4 dried shiitake mushrooms (about 10 g)

Seasoning

  • 1 tbsp sake
  • 2 tsp light (usukuchi) soy sauce, or 1½ tsp regular soy sauce
  • ¾ tsp fine sea salt, or to taste

In the bowl

  • 7 oz (200 g) soft or silken tofu, cut into ¾-inch (2 cm) cubes
  • 3½ oz (100 g) enoki mushrooms, roots trimmed, separated into small bunches
  • 4 fresh shiitake mushrooms, stems removed, thinly sliced
  • 2-inch (5 cm) piece fresh ginger, peeled
  • 2 scallions, green parts only, thinly sliced
  • Chinese black vinegar, to serve (optional)

Steep slowly, season first, warm gently

  1. 1 Put the water, kombu and dried shiitake in a medium saucepan and soak for 30 minutes.
  2. 2 Set the pan over medium-low heat and bring it slowly toward a simmer, about 10 minutes. When small bubbles form around the edge, at about 150°F (65°C), lift out the kombu and discard it.
  3. 3 Let the broth come to a gentle simmer and cook the shiitake 5 minutes. Lift them out, squeeze them back into the pot, then slice the caps thinly and return them. Discard the stems.
  4. 4 Season the broth with the sake, soy sauce and salt. Taste it on its own and adjust: it should taste fully seasoned and a little salty.
  5. 5 Lower the heat until the broth is barely moving. Add the fresh shiitake and enoki and cook 2 minutes.
  6. 6 Slide in the tofu and leave it 2–3 minutes, without stirring or boiling, until hot through.
  7. 7 Finely grate the ginger, then squeeze the gratings in your fingers over a small bowl to collect about 2 teaspoons of juice. Stir the juice into the soup off the heat.
  8. 8 Ladle into bowls, scatter with scallions and add a teaspoon of black vinegar to each bowl if you like. Serve right away.

Shortcuts, additions and making it ahead

  • Instant dashi powder made from kombu and shiitake works in a hurry. Most dashi powder contains bonito, which makes it not vegan; check the label.
  • The dashi can be made up to 3 days ahead and refrigerated. Season it and add the tofu and mushrooms only when you reheat it.
  • Firm tofu holds its shape better if you would rather stir freely, but it is chewier and drinks up less broth.
  • Other good additions: a handful of baby spinach in the last minute, a few slices of carrot cut into flowers, or wakame soaked for 5 minutes.
  • For a non-vegan version, add a handful of bonito flakes to the broth when the kombu comes out, steep 2 minutes off the heat, and strain.

Cloudy broth, black vinegar and tofu

The kombu was boiled, the broth boiled hard after the tofu went in, or grated ginger was added instead of the juice. Keep the kombu below a simmer, keep the soup barely moving at the end, and squeeze the ginger.

This is a Japanese clear soup: dashi, salt and light soy, and very little else. A spoonful of Chinese black vinegar and plenty of ginger takes it toward a Chinese hot and sour style without the cornstarch. Add the vinegar in the bowl so each person can choose.

Soft or silken tofu for the most delicate texture. It needs gentle heat and no stirring. Medium or firm tofu is easier to handle and fine if you prefer some chew.

Yes. Use about a quarter less and add a pinch more salt. The broth will be a little darker, which is the only real difference.

Yes, as written. The broth is kombu and shiitake only. It stops being vegan if you use a dashi powder made with bonito.